Did the Bible Remember a Forgotten Empire? The Rediscovery of the Hittites

For centuries the Hittites were known only from the Bible, and in 1847 a critic called its picture of Hittite kings unhistorical. Then Hattusa and its tablets came out of the ground. What was found, what the critics actually said, and what is still debated about the Bible's Hittites.

The Old Testament names the Hittites again and again. Abraham buys a grave for Sarah from Ephron the Hittite. Esau marries Hittite women. Uriah the Hittite fights among David's mighty men. Solomon's merchants sell chariots to "the kings of the Hittites." Yet for most of Christian history, readers knew almost nothing about this people beyond what Scripture said. No Hittite city had been identified, no Hittite text could be read, and no history book outside the Bible told their story.

That changed between the 1820s and the 1910s. Egyptian and Assyrian inscriptions were deciphered, strange carved stones were noticed in Syria, and in 1906 excavators at a Turkish village called Boğazköy found the royal archives of a lost empire. The "forgotten empire," as one Victorian scholar called it, had been a great power of the Bronze Age, a rival of Egypt with its own kings, treaties, gods and laws.

The story is often told as a simple victory: skeptics said the Hittites never existed, and the spade proved the Bible right. The real history is more interesting, and it is better evidence for the trustworthiness of Scripture when it is told accurately. This article sets out what was found, what the critics actually said, and where honest questions remain.

In brief

The Bible mentions the Hittites dozens of times, from Genesis to the books of Kings. By the nineteenth century the people behind the name had dropped out of human memory except for these references. Egyptian records, once Champollion had deciphered hieroglyphs in 1822, spoke of a northern power called Kheta; Assyrian records spoke of the land of Hatti. In 1847 the English writer F. W. Newman judged the Bible's mention of powerful "kings of the Hittites" (2 Kings 7:6) to be unhistorical. Within forty years, carved monuments in Syria and Anatolia had been connected with the Hittites, and in 1906 Hugo Winckler and Theodor Makridi began excavating Hattusa, the Hittite capital, uncovering thousands of clay tablets. In 1915 Bedřich Hrozný showed that the Hittite language is Indo-European, the oldest written member of that family. The tablets revealed an empire that fought Egypt at Kadesh and made a peace treaty with Ramesses II. After the empire fell around 1180 BC, Hittite successor kingdoms in Syria lived on into the age of Solomon and Elisha, exactly where the books of Kings place "the kings of the Hittites." Whether the Hittites of Abraham's Hebron were connected with the Anatolian empire is still debated.

Thesis: The rediscovery of the Hittites did not "prove the Bible" in one stroke, but it overturned a confident critical judgment against Scripture and showed that the biblical writers knew the political world they described.

The Hittites in Scripture

Hittites appear in the Table of Nations, where Heth is listed among the sons of Canaan (Genesis 10:15), and in the lists of peoples living in the Promised Land (Genesis 15:20; Exodus 3:8). In the Greek Old Testament that the Church received, they are the Chettaioi (Genesis 10:15), and in Genesis 23 the "sons of Heth" are the "sons of Chet." The references fall into a few groups.

  • Neighbors in Canaan. Abraham, "a stranger and a foreigner," asks "the children of Heth" for a burying place at Hebron and weighs out "four hundred shekels of silver" to Ephron for the field and cave of Machpelah (Genesis 23:3-4, 16). Esau marries "Judith, the daughter of Beeri the Hittite, and Basemath, the daughter of Elon the Hittite," and "they grieved Isaac's and Rebekah's spirits" (Genesis 26:34-35). Numbers 13:29 places Hittites in the hill country.
  • Men in David's service. Ahimelech the Hittite was with David in the wilderness (1 Samuel 26:6), and Uriah the Hittite, Bathsheba's husband, is named among David's mighty men (2 Samuel 11:3; 23:39).
  • Kingdoms to the north. Israel's border is to reach "all the land of the Hittites" toward the Euphrates (Joshua 1:4). A man from Bethel goes "into the land of the Hittites" and builds a city (Judges 1:26). Solomon's traders export chariots and horses "to all the kings of the Hittites and to the kings of Syria" (1 Kings 10:29), and Solomon takes Hittite wives (1 Kings 11:1). In the days of Elisha, the Syrian army besieging Samaria panics because it thinks "the king of Israel has hired against us the kings of the Hittites and the kings of the Egyptians to attack us" (2 Kings 7:6).

The writers treat these people as an ordinary part of the world: landowners, soldiers, in-laws, trading partners and military powers. They are never described as a people of legend.

A people the world forgot

Classical Greek and Roman historians, who preserved so much about Egypt, Babylon and Persia, have almost nothing to say about the Hittites. By their time the empire had been gone for centuries. Its capital lay in ruins on the Anatolian plateau, its language was no longer spoken, and its two scripts, cuneiform and a hieroglyphic script carved on monuments, could no longer be read. For a Christian reader in 1800, the Hittites existed only in the Bible.

Even the name is a modern borrowing. The people of the empire spoke of "the land of Hatti," a name taken from the older, non-Indo-European Hattians who lived there before them, and they called their own language nesili, "the language of Nesa" (the city of Kanesh). Scholars took up the biblical word "Hittite" for the whole civilization once it came to light.1

Clues from Egypt, Assyria and Syria

The first clues came from other peoples' records. The Rosetta Stone, found in Egypt in 1799, gave Jean-François Champollion the key to Egyptian hieroglyphs, and his decipherment was announced in 1822. Egyptian temple inscriptions turned out to speak of wars with a northern kingdom called Kheta (Hatti). As Assyrian cuneiform was deciphered in the following decades, Assyrian royal annals were found to speak of "the land of Hatti" as well, by then meaning the kingdoms of northern Syria.2

Meanwhile travelers were noticing monuments no one could read. In 1812 the Swiss explorer Johann Ludwig Burckhardt reported a stone covered with hieroglyph-like signs set into a wall at Hama in Syria (biblical Hamath). In 1834 the French traveler Charles Texier came upon huge ruins near the village of Boğazköy in central Anatolia, with massive walls, carved gates and the nearby rock sanctuary now called Yazılıkaya. He published drawings of them, but he did not know whose city it was.3

In the 1870s and 1880s two British scholars drew the threads together. The Assyriologist Archibald Henry Sayce argued that the strange hieroglyphic monuments of Syria and Anatolia were Hittite, and the missionary William Wright, who had helped secure the Hama stones for the museum in Constantinople, published The Empire of the Hittites in 1884. Sayce's popular book of 1888 bore a title that has stuck to the subject ever since: The Hittites: The Story of a Forgotten Empire.4

The critic who doubted 2 Kings 7:6

Popular retellings often say that "critics denied the Hittites ever existed." That overstates what can be documented. No one doubted that Scripture named a people called Hittites. What some critics doubted was the Bible's picture of the Hittites as a significant power in the days of the kings.

The clearest case is Francis William Newman, a former fellow of Balliol College, Oxford (and brother of John Henry Newman), in A History of the Hebrew Monarchy (1847). Writing on the siege of Samaria in 2 Kings 6-7, Newman said that "the unhistorical tone is far too manifest to allow of our easy belief in it," and in a footnote he dismissed the Syrians' fear of the Hittite kings: "No Hittite kings can have compared in power with the king of Judah, the real and nearer ally, who is not named at all."5

Forty years later Sayce quoted this passage on the first pages of his book and replied that recent discoveries had "retorted the critic's objections upon himself. It is not the Biblical writer but the modern author who is now proved to have been unacquainted with the contemporaneous history of the time. The Hittites were a very real power."6 {{strong: In the ninth century BC, the age of Elisha, Hittite successor kingdoms such as Carchemish and Hamath were real powers in northern Syria, whose kings appear in Assyrian annals as opponents of the Assyrian armies, Irhuleni of Hamath among the coalition at Qarqar in 853 BC.}} The Syrian soldiers' fear in 2 Kings 7:6 fits that world.

The honest lesson is narrower than the legend, and stronger for it. A learned critic judged a detail of Scripture unhistorical because nothing outside the Bible confirmed it. The evidence had not disappeared; it simply had not yet been found and read.

Hattusa speaks

In 1906 the German Assyriologist Hugo Winckler and Theodor Makridi of the Imperial Ottoman Museum in Constantinople began digging at Boğazköy, the ruins Texier had drawn seventy years earlier. Within weeks they found clay tablets by the thousand. Many were written in Akkadian, the diplomatic language of the age, which Winckler could read at once; many more were in an unknown language written in the same cuneiform signs.7

The Akkadian tablets settled the city's identity. This was Hattusa, capital of the kings of Hatti. Among the finds was the Akkadian text of the peace treaty between the Hittite king Hattusili III and Ramesses II of Egypt, a treaty already known from its Egyptian version carved on temple walls at Karnak and at the Ramesseum in Thebes.8 Excavation has continued, mostly under the German Archaeological Institute, for more than a century. The Boğazköy archives have yielded some 25,000 to 30,000 tablets and fragments, depending on how fragments are counted: treaties, letters, laws, royal annals, oracles, rituals, prayers and hymns. UNESCO listed Hattusha as a World Heritage Site in 1986, and the Hittite tablets from Boğazköy were added to its Memory of the World Register in 2001.9

The city itself matched the archives. Its walls ran for kilometers around an upper and a lower town, with temples, storerooms and a royal citadel. Visitors today still walk through the Lion Gate, flanked by two lions carved from the stone of the gateway.

A great power of the Bronze Age

The tablets showed that at its height, in the fourteenth and thirteenth centuries BC, the Hittite kingdom ruled most of Anatolia and northern Syria and stood among the great powers of the age with Egypt, Babylon, Assyria and Mitanni. Its kings wrote to the pharaohs as equals and addressed them as "my brother."

The rivalry with Egypt came to a head at Kadesh, on the Orontes River in Syria, around 1274 BC, when Ramesses II met the army of the Hittite king Muwatalli II. Ramesses had the battle carved on temple walls as a great personal triumph, but the result was at best a draw: Kadesh stayed in Hittite hands.10 About fifteen years later, around 1259 BC, Ramesses II and Hattusili III made a treaty of peace and mutual defense. {{very-strong: The treaty between Egypt and the Hittites survives in two versions, the Egyptian one carved at Karnak and the Ramesseum and the Akkadian one on tablets from Hattusa, so this ancient peace can be read from both sides.}} A copper replica of the treaty, given by Turkey in 1970, hangs near the Security Council chamber at the United Nations headquarters in New York.

The empire collapsed around 1180 BC, during the wider upheaval at the end of the Bronze Age, and Hattusa was abandoned. The last known Great King was Suppiluliuma II.11

The oldest written Indo-European language

The unknown language of the tablets was the next puzzle. As early as 1902 the Norwegian scholar Jørgen Alexander Knudtzon had suggested that two letters found in the Egyptian archive at Amarna, written in this language, were Indo-European. Most scholars rejected the idea at the time.

In 1915 the Czech scholar Bedřich Hrozný proved him right. His starting point was a sentence that reads, in transcription, nu NINDA-an ezzateni watar-ma ekutteni. The Sumerian sign NINDA meant "bread," watar looked like English "water" and German Wasser, and ezza- looked like the root of Latin edere and German essen, "to eat." Hrozný read it: "Now you will eat bread and drink water." He published his solution that year and a full grammar in 1917.12

Hittite turned out to be the earliest Indo-European language preserved in writing, related to Greek, Latin, Sanskrit and, distantly, English. Its texts reach back to the seventeenth century BC, and Hittite names and words appear even earlier in Assyrian merchant records from Kanesh. The hieroglyphic monuments of Syria that had first drawn Sayce's attention were later shown to be written in Luwian, a closely related language.13

Were the Bible's Hittites the same people?

Here care is needed. The Bible uses "Hittite" for more than one group, and historians do not think all of them were subjects of the empire ruled from Hattusa.

The kings of the Hittites in Solomon's and Elisha's day. After the empire fell, a cluster of kingdoms in southeastern Anatolia and northern Syria kept its royal names, its art and the Luwian hieroglyphic script. Carchemish, ruled for a time by a branch of the Hittite royal family, was the most important. Historians call these the Neo-Hittite or Syro-Hittite states, and Assyrian kings went on calling the whole region "Hatti." When 1 Kings 10:29 and 2 Kings 7:6 speak of "the kings of the Hittites," often alongside the kings of Syria and Egypt, they describe exactly this world of the tenth and ninth centuries BC.14 Joshua 1:4 and Judges 1:26, which place "the land of the Hittites" in the north toward the Euphrates, fit the same geography.

The children of Heth at Hebron. The Hittites of Genesis are another matter. Ephron, Judith, Beeri, Basemath and Elon all bear Semitic names, and Genesis presents them as settled local people in the hill country of Canaan, far south of any territory the Anatolian empire is known to have ruled. Scholars disagree about who they were. Some, following the Hittitologist Harry Hoffner, see them as a local Canaanite group whose name sounded like that of the northern Hittites but who were not connected with them. Others think small groups from the north had settled in Canaan. Another view is that the later name was applied to an older local people. The evidence does not yet decide the question.15

Uriah may belong to either group. His name is Hebrew and contains the divine name ("the Lord is my light"), so whatever his ancestry, he served Israel's God and Israel's king.

The same caution applies to Genesis 23. In 1953 Manfred Lehmann argued that Abraham's purchase of Machpelah followed details of Hittite law. Later study, notably by Gene Tucker and Harry Hoffner, found the parallels weak and argued that the closest parallels are general ancient Near Eastern sale documents. Christians should not repeat the "Hittite law" argument as if it were settled.16

Objections and responses

"The skeptics who denied the Hittites are an apologetic myth."

Partly true, and worth admitting. We know of no scholar who claimed the biblical writers invented the name. But Newman's judgment is a documented case of a critic calling a specific biblical statement about Hittite power unhistorical, and Sayce, who answered him in 1888, was a contemporary witness to the debate. The fair way to tell the story is the way it happened.

"The Bible's Hittites in Canaan are an anachronism, so the rediscovery does not help."

The rediscovery helps where the Bible speaks of Hittite kings and of a land of the Hittites in the north: there the fit is close, and it was not known in 1847. For Genesis, the honest answer is that the identity of the children of Heth is unsettled, and a name shared by two peoples is not proof of error. Ancient sources often use one name for different groups, as Assyrian scribes did with "Hatti."

"Archaeology can confirm a setting, not a miracle."

True. Hattusa does not prove that the Lord made the Syrian army hear the sound of chariots. What it shows is that the narrative is set in a real world that the writer knew. The claim that the Bible's historical framework was invented has failed here, and a document that is reliable where it can be checked deserves to be heard where it cannot.

What we can say confidently

  • The Hittite kingdom, centered at Hattusa (Boğazköy, Turkey), was a great power of the Late Bronze Age that rivaled Egypt in Syria.
  • Its capital was identified when excavations began in 1906, and its archives have produced tens of thousands of tablets and fragments.
  • Hittite is the earliest Indo-European language preserved in writing; Hrozný demonstrated this in 1915.
  • Egypt and the Hittites fought at Kadesh around 1274 BC and made a peace treaty around 1259 BC that survives in both Egyptian and Akkadian versions.
  • Hittite successor kingdoms in northern Syria flourished in the tenth to eighth centuries BC, matching the "kings of the Hittites" in 1 and 2 Kings.
  • A leading critic in 1847 judged 2 Kings 7:6 unhistorical for lack of outside evidence, and later discoveries removed the basis for his objection.

What remains disputed

  • Who the "children of Heth" at Hebron in Genesis were, and whether they had any link with the Anatolian Hittites.
  • Whether Genesis 23 reflects any specifically Hittite legal custom (most recent scholars say no).
  • The exact dates of Hittite kings and of the Battle of Kadesh, which depend on debated Egyptian chronology (1274 BC is the most widely used date).
  • The precise causes of the empire's collapse around 1180 BC.

Conclusion: the Church reads Scripture as true history

The Orthodox Church receives the Old Testament as Holy Scripture, inspired by the Holy Spirit and read within the Church's Tradition. That faith does not depend on archaeology, and the Church did not wait for Winckler's spade to trust the books of Kings. But the story of the Hittites is a fair warning against a habit of mind. Newman treated the silence of the evidence as proof that Scripture was wrong. The silence ended, and his objection did not survive. Archaeology still leaves questions open, and we should say so plainly. On the question that was actually tested, though, the biblical writer knew the world better than his modern critic did.

There is a quieter reason this people matters to Christians. Every year, on the Sunday before the Nativity, the Church reads the genealogy of Christ from the first chapter of Matthew, and in it is a Hittite's name: "David the king became the father of Solomon by her who had been Uriah's wife" (Matthew 1:6). St John Chrysostom, preaching on the genealogy, said that the evangelist named foreigners and sinners among Christ's ancestors "that you may learn that He came to do away with all our ills. For He has come as a Physician, not as a Judge."17 The forgotten empire is a footnote to world history, but Uriah, a foreigner who was loyal to Israel's God and wronged by Israel's king, is remembered in the Gospel itself.

For more on how archaeology bears on the Old Testament, see our articles on the Tel Dan Stele and King David, Sennacherib's siege of Jerusalem and the Exodus and the Merneptah Stele, and explore the sites on our Biblical Archaeology map. On how the Church reads these books, see How Should Christians Read the Old Testament? and Why Is the Orthodox Old Testament Bigger?

Notes

  1. Trevor Bryce, The Kingdom of the Hittites, new ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005); Billie Jean Collins, The Hittites and Their World (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2007).
  2. Bryce, Kingdom of the Hittites; Collins, Hittites and Their World.
  3. Charles Texier, Description de l'Asie Mineure, 3 vols. (Paris: Firmin Didot, 1839-1849), vol. 1; Collins, Hittites and Their World.
  4. A. H. Sayce, The Hittites: The Story of a Forgotten Empire (London: Religious Tract Society, 1888); William Wright, The Empire of the Hittites (London: James Nisbet, 1884).
  5. Francis William Newman, A History of the Hebrew Monarchy from the Administration of Samuel to the Babylonish Captivity (London: John Chapman, 1847), 197 and 199 n. 1.
  6. Sayce, The Hittites, ch. 1.
  7. Bryce, Kingdom of the Hittites; Collins, Hittites and Their World.
  8. Gary Beckman, Hittite Diplomatic Texts, 2nd ed. (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1999), no. 15.
  9. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, "Hattusha: the Hittite Capital" (inscribed 1986), https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/377/; UNESCO Memory of the World, "The Hittite cuneiform tablets from Bogazköy" (inscribed 2001).
  10. Bryce, Kingdom of the Hittites.
  11. Bryce, Kingdom of the Hittites.
  12. Bedřich Hrozný, "Die Lösung des hethitischen Problems," Mitteilungen der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 56 (1915); Hrozný, Die Sprache der Hethiter (Leipzig: Hinrichs, 1917); J. A. Knudtzon, Die zwei Arzawa-Briefe (Leipzig: Hinrichs, 1902).
  13. Collins, Hittites and Their World; Annick Payne, Iron Age Hieroglyphic Luwian Inscriptions (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2012).
  14. Payne, Iron Age Hieroglyphic Luwian Inscriptions; Collins, Hittites and Their World.
  15. Harry A. Hoffner Jr., "Hittites," in Peoples of the Old Testament World, ed. Alfred J. Hoerth, Gerald L. Mattingly and Edwin M. Yamauchi (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1994); Collins, Hittites and Their World.
  16. Manfred R. Lehmann, "Abraham's Purchase of Machpelah and Hittite Law," Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 129 (1953): 15-18; Gene M. Tucker, "The Legal Background of Genesis 23," Journal of Biblical Literature 85 (1966): 77-84.
  17. St John Chrysostom, Homilies on Matthew 3.5, trans. George Prevost, rev. M. B. Riddle, NPNF1 vol. 10.

Bibliography

Primary sources

  • The Holy Bible, World English Bible (public domain).
  • Beckman, Gary. Hittite Diplomatic Texts. 2nd ed. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1999.
  • Texier, Charles. Description de l'Asie Mineure. 3 vols. Paris: Firmin Didot, 1839-1849.

Orthodox and patristic sources

  • St John Chrysostom. Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew. Translated by George Prevost, revised by M. B. Riddle. Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, vol. 10. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200103.htm

Other scholarship

  • Bryce, Trevor. The Kingdom of the Hittites. New ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.
  • Collins, Billie Jean. The Hittites and Their World. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2007.
  • Hoffner, Harry A., Jr. "Hittites." In Peoples of the Old Testament World, edited by Alfred J. Hoerth, Gerald L. Mattingly and Edwin M. Yamauchi. Grand Rapids: Baker, 1994.
  • Hrozný, Bedřich. "Die Lösung des hethitischen Problems." Mitteilungen der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 56 (1915).
  • Hrozný, Bedřich. Die Sprache der Hethiter. Leipzig: Hinrichs, 1917.
  • Knudtzon, J. A. Die zwei Arzawa-Briefe. Leipzig: Hinrichs, 1902.
  • Lehmann, Manfred R. "Abraham's Purchase of Machpelah and Hittite Law." Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 129 (1953): 15-18.
  • Payne, Annick. Iron Age Hieroglyphic Luwian Inscriptions. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2012.
  • Sayce, A. H. The Hittites: The Story of a Forgotten Empire. London: Religious Tract Society, 1888.
  • Tucker, Gene M. "The Legal Background of Genesis 23." Journal of Biblical Literature 85 (1966): 77-84.
  • UNESCO World Heritage Centre. "Hattusha: the Hittite Capital." https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/377/
  • Wright, William. The Empire of the Hittites. London: James Nisbet, 1884.

Critical sources

  • Newman, Francis William. A History of the Hebrew Monarchy from the Administration of Samuel to the Babylonish Captivity. London: John Chapman, 1847.

Continue your study