Which Bible should I read?

Leer en español

Why this page exists

Most Bible websites list translations with no word about where they come from. Readers aren't told whether a version was made by Protestants, Catholics, the Orthodox Church, Jewish scholars or one individual. They aren't told which Old Testament it translates or which books it leaves out. We think readers deserve to know. Every Bible on this site carries a short, plain label covering five things: who made it, what it was translated from, which books it contains, how literally it translates, and what its licence allows.

We write as Eastern Orthodox Christians, and we say so openly. We have tried to describe every tradition the way its own members would recognise.

1. Two Old Testaments: the Hebrew and the Greek

Christians have received the Old Testament in two main forms.

The Masoretic Text (Hebrew). This is the authoritative Hebrew text of Rabbinic Judaism. It is named after the Masoretes, the medieval scribes who added vowel points and notes. The oldest complete manuscript is the Leningrad Codex, copied in Cairo in AD 1008 or 1009 [S1, S2]. It is the basis of almost all Protestant Old Testaments, including the KJV, ASV, WEB and BSB. Since the mid-20th century it has also been the basis of most modern Catholic translations [S2].

The Septuagint (Greek, "LXX"). This is the Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures made by Jews in Egypt. Scholars date the translation of the Torah with confidence to the mid- or late 3rd century BC. The other books followed over the next two centuries or so [S3]. The Septuagint also contains books and passages not found in the Hebrew Bible: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, 1–4 Maccabees, 1 Esdras, the Greek parts of Esther and Daniel, the Prayer of Manasseh, Psalm 151 and others [S3].

Fair points on both sides.

A verse you can check yourself. Hebrews 10:5 quotes Psalm 40 as "a body you prepared for me". That is the Septuagint wording: Brenton's translation of Psalm 39:7 LXX reads "a body hast thou prepared me". The Hebrew-based Psalm 40:6 reads "You have opened my ears" [S4]. This is one reason the Greek Old Testament matters to Christians: the Apostles often quote it.

Another, handled carefully. In Isaiah 7:14 the Septuagint reads "virgin" (parthenos), and Matthew 1:23 quotes that wording. The 1917 Jewish Publication Society translation of the Hebrew reads "the young woman" [S5]. Both renderings come from the same Hebrew word (almah), and their meaning has been debated since the 2nd century. St Justin Martyr already argued the point with a Jewish interlocutor around AD 160 [S6].

2. Why the Orthodox Church reads the Septuagint

The Eastern Orthodox Church uses the Septuagint as its Old Testament. Where Greek is the liturgical language, it reads the Septuagint in Greek. Elsewhere it uses the Septuagint as the basis for translations into other languages [S3, S7]. The reasons are historical and theological, not a dislike of Hebrew:

  1. It was the Bible of the Apostolic Church in the Greek-speaking world. The New Testament writers frequently quote the Old Testament in its Greek form (see Hebrews 10:5 above) [S3, S4].
  2. The Fathers received it. St Augustine, a Western Father, records that the Church received the Septuagint as though it were the only Greek translation, although others existed. He reports that Jerome's new Latin translation from the Hebrew was respected, but that the churches did not set it above the authority of the Seventy. Augustine held that where the two differ, both can carry the Spirit's meaning [S8].
  3. The extra books are part of the Church's inheritance. The Orthodox Church reads Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Maccabees and the rest as Scripture "found only in the Septuagint" [S7] (the OCA's wording). It calls them the anagignoskomena, "the books that are read" [S9].

Being fair: the Orthodox Church does not reject the Hebrew text. Orthodox scholars study it.

3. Which books are in the Bible? (Canons)

TraditionOld TestamentNotes
Jewish (Tanakh)24 books (= the 39 of Protestant Bibles, counted differently)Hebrew order: Torah, Prophets, Writings [S11].
Protestant39 books → 66 totalAfter the Reformation, Protestant Bibles followed the Jewish canon. The Septuagint's extra books were called "Apocrypha". Early Protestant Bibles (KJV 1611, Geneva 1560, Reina 1569) still printed them, often in a separate section [S3, S11, S12]. Anglicans accept them "for instruction in life and manners, but not for the establishment of doctrine", as do Lutherans in a similar way [S11].
Catholic46 books → 73 totalConfirmed by the Council of Trent on 8 April 1546. The "deuterocanonical" books are Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, 1–2 Maccabees and the Greek parts of Esther and Daniel. The Clementine Vulgate printed the Prayer of Manasseh and 3–4 Esdras in an appendix, as non-canonical [S11].
Eastern OrthodoxThe Catholic list plus 1 Esdras, 3 Maccabees, the Prayer of Manasseh and Psalm 151; 4 Maccabees is commonly printed in an appendixThe Greek Orthodox reckon Psalm 151 part of the Psalter. They count four books of Maccabees, the fourth usually in an appendix with the Prayer of Manasseh. For the Greeks the "two books of Esdras" are 1 Esdras and Ezra–Nehemiah [S9]. The Synod of Jerusalem (1672) affirmed Wisdom, Judith, Tobit, Susanna, Bel and the Dragon, the Maccabees and Sirach as "genuine parts of Scripture" [S9]. As a local council, its decrees bind only as far as they are received by the Orthodox Churches [S9]. Editions differ: one Antiochian parish guide says only that "some editions" include 3–4 Maccabees, Psalm 151, 1 Esdras and the Prayer of Manasseh [S14].
Oriental OrthodoxVaries; the Ethiopian canon is the broadestThe Ethiopian Church accepts the Catholic and Orthodox extra books except the four Maccabees, and has its own wider list [S11]. Not covered by this reader.

The New Testament has the same 27 books in the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant Churches [S11].

In this reader each translation carries a canon label: Protestant (66 books), Protestant, with the Apocrypha, Catholic (73 books), All books (ecumenical), Septuagint Old Testament, Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) or New Testament only. Where the Orthodox books are present, we say which ones.

4. Which Greek New Testament? (TR, Byzantine, Patriarchal, Critical)

All New Testament translations rest on Greek manuscripts. The differences between printed Greek texts are real but usually small.

A test case: 1 John 5:7–8 ("three that bear witness in heaven").

So the traditional Orthodox text is not simply "the TR", and it is not simply the "majority" either. This is why the reader labels each New Testament precisely.

5. How literally does it translate?

Broadly, translations fall into these kinds (the badge on each translation uses similar terms: very literal, formal, dynamic, simplified, paraphrase). Real translations sit on a spectrum.

Literal translations help with study. Freer ones help with first reading and with children. Neither is "the real Bible" while the other is fake. Comparing two is often the wisest course.

6. So which should I read?

If you are Orthodox, or want to read as the Orthodox Church reads:

If you are Catholic: the Douay-Rheims (Challoner), which carries a cardinal's approbation [S30]. There is also the modern-English Catholic Public Domain Version, which has no imprimatur and is the work of one translator [S31]. In Spanish, the Scío New Testament (translated from the Vulgate; authorised in Spain in 1782) [S32].

If you are Protestant: the King James Version, the Berean Standard Bible or the World English Bible. In Spanish, the Reina-Valera 1909, or for plainer Spanish, Palabra de Dios para ti or the Nueva Biblia Viva.

If you want to see how Jewish tradition reads the Hebrew: the JPS Tanakh (1917) [S5].

If English is not your first language, or for children: the Bible in Basic English, or La Biblia en Español Sencillo in Spanish.

7. An honest gap

We searched for an openly licensed translation made by the Orthodox Church in English or Spanish. We found none we are allowed to host:

The public-domain text that best fits the Orthodox Church's own Bible is in Greek: the Patriarchal Text for the New Testament and the Septuagint for the Old. We say this plainly rather than present a Protestant or Catholic translation as if it were Orthodox.

Sources

  1. S1 Wikipedia, "Leningrad Codex" (secondary): dated 1008/1009, Cairo; basis of BHS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leningrad_Codex
  2. S2 Wikipedia, "Masoretic Text" (secondary): definition; oldest complete copies; basis of Protestant OTs and post-1943 Catholic Bibles; DSS plurality and proto-Masoretic majority. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masoretic_Text
  3. S3 Wikipedia, "Septuagint" (secondary): dating; extra books; Orthodox use; manuscripts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Septuagint
  4. S4 Texts checked on eBible.org: Brenton Ps 39 https://ebible.org/eng-Brenton/PSA039.htm ; WEB Ps 40 https://ebible.org/engwebp/PSA040.htm ; WEB Heb 10 https://ebible.org/engwebp/HEB10.htm
  5. S5 JPS 1917 Isaiah 7:14 https://ebible.org/engjps/ISA07.htm ; Brenton Isaiah 7:14 https://ebible.org/eng-Brenton/ISA07.htm
  6. S6 St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 71–73, 84 (New Advent translation). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/01286.htm
  7. S7 Orthodox Church in America, "Canon of Scripture" (Q&A). https://oca.org/questions/scripture/canon-of-scripture
  8. S8 St Augustine, City of God XVIII.42–44 (New Advent). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/120118.htm
  9. S9 OrthodoxWiki, "Old Testament Canon": Psalm 151; four Maccabees with 4 Macc in appendix; 1 Esdras; Synod of Jerusalem 1672 and its status. https://orthodoxwiki.org/Old_Testament_Canon ; Wikipedia, "Biblical canon": anagignoskomena. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_canon
  10. S11 Wikipedia, "Biblical canon" (secondary): Tanakh 24 books; Trent 8 April 1546; Clementine appendix; Anglican position; Ethiopian canon; NT 27. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_canon
  11. S12 eBible.org KJV + Apocrypha https://ebible.org/eng-kjv/copyright.htm ; Wikipedia "Reina-Valera" (1569 included deuterocanon) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reina-Valera
  12. S14 St Michael Antiochian Orthodox Church (Texas), "What books are in the Orthodox Old Testament?" https://stmichaeltx.org/orthodox-101/scripture-tradition/what-books-are-in-the-orthodox-old-testament/
  13. S15 Wikipedia, "Textus Receptus" and "Byzantine text-type" (secondary). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textus_Receptus ; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_text-type
  14. S16 byztxt, Scrivener 1894 TR (public domain). https://github.com/byztxt/greektext-scrivener
  15. S17 byztxt, Robinson–Pierpont Byzantine Majority Text (public domain). https://github.com/byztxt/byzantine-majority-text
  16. S18 eBible.org, RP disclaimer quoted in the Text-Critical GNT copyright page. https://ebible.org/grctcgnt/copyright.htm
  17. S19 Wikipedia, "Patriarchal text" (secondary): 22 Feb 1904; revisions 1907, 1912; not universally accepted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriarchal_text
  18. S20 Introduction to the Antoniades 1904 edition, trans. J. M. Rife (1933), in byztxt `ANTINTRO.TXT`. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/byztxt/greektext-antoniades/master/textonly/ANTINTRO.TXT
  19. S21 SBLGNT licence and Wikipedia "SBL Greek New Testament". https://sblgnt.com/license/ ; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SBL_Greek_New_Testament
  20. S22 1 John 5 on eBible: TR https://ebible.org/grctr/1JN05.htm ; RP https://ebible.org/grcmt/1JN05.htm ; SBLGNT https://ebible.org/grcsbl/1JN05.htm ; Patriarchal (eBible, double-bracketed) https://ebible.org/grcbyz/1JN05.htm
  21. S23 Wikipedia, "Young's Literal Translation". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young%27s_Literal_Translation
  22. S24 Berean Bibles FAQ. https://bereanbibles.com/about-berean-study-bible/faqs/
  23. S25 T4T preface. https://ebible.org/eng-t4t/FRT01.htm
  24. S26 eBible Brenton book list and copyright; IOSCS on Brenton. https://ebible.org/eng-Brenton/copyright.htm ; https://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/ioscs/brenton/
  25. S27 WEB FAQ. https://eBible.org/eng-web/webfaq.htm ; Majority Standard Bible https://majoritybible.com/
  26. S28 Wikipedia, "Orthodox Study Bible". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthodox_Study_Bible
  27. S29 EOB permission notice, in The Holy Gospel (Saint Ignatius Orthodox Press, 2018). https://legacyicons.com/content/gospel-look-inside-web.pdf
  28. S30 CrossWire DRC module (title page: approbation of Cardinal Gibbons). https://www.crosswire.org/sword/modules/ModInfo.jsp?modName=DRC
  29. S31 CrossWire CPDV module; SacredBible.org. https://www.crosswire.org/sword/modules/ModInfo.jsp?modName=CPDV ; https://www.sacredbible.org/
  30. S32 Wikipedia (es), "Biblia de Scío"; CrossWire SpaScioNT. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblia_de_Sc%C3%ADo ; https://www.crosswire.org/sword/modules/ModInfo.jsp?modName=SpaScioNT
  31. S33 eBible front matter, Biblia libre para el mundo. https://ebible.org/pdf/spablm/spablm_INT.pdf

We have left out a few statements from our research notes that we could not verify against a source we opened.